SpaceX Showed The Risk Of IPO Hype—Anthropic Could Be Next
econews. Investors chasing a hot IPO may want to resist the urge to buy on day one. SpaceX shares fell below their $135 IPO price just 34 days after their debut, and Anthropic could cross that threshold even faster, with its shares already trading close to its $83 IPO price on their first day. For retail investors, the lesson is less about whether the companies will ultimately prove successful and more about the price investors pay to own them. When IPO hype is running high, waiting for the excitement and initial price swings to settle can offer a better entry point.
Deliberate work lies behind IPOs to make them sound as important and valuable as possible. That is a responsibility of the banks hired to sell the event. A company going through an IPO is, among other things, raising money so it can further follow its goals and strategy and also repay early investors who want to see the return they expected from day one.
Lots of shares will change hands, and the sellers look to offload their spare shares to institutions, but more so to retail investors who might think they’re getting an in and will pay more.
There is nothing inherently wrong with promoting an IPO. It’s the levels of hype companies and their bankers employ to bring in the cash from regular people, because the well-moneyed organizations have experts, detailed research and resources to help them make the best decision for them. Additionally, they have enough capital and experience to realize that not all investments will work out, and typically they can hedge their bets. Lose one today, win more tomorrow.
Most retail investors don’t have this, and they are more susceptible to the marketers’ expertise in persuasion.
You’ve probably heard the phrase, “Buy on the dip.” With IPOs, at least today, particularly with the heavily hyped ones, that is wise advice.
In the week that SpaceX shares fell below the IPO price, The Motley Fool looked at 10 of the biggest IPOs, including Rivian Automotive and Coupang. Eight posted declines in the three months following their launch. Five of those ultimately had double-digit declines. The average drop over the first three months was 13%.
For SpaceX, the IPO price was $135. For some significant stretches, and currently, the price has been below that figure. And if you’re an average retail investor who bought at the IPO, you didn’t get shares for that cheap. You might have paid a premium of 10%, 15%, 20% or even more. Those who run the IPO process, and whom sellers trust to uncover the best price, try to ensure an initial jump so insiders can make money if they’re allowed to sell their shares.
But no one sets the price thinking that it should or would crash immediately. As of 1:50 p.m. Eastern time, Anthropic share prices were hovering between about $84.50 and a little above $87. At 11:44 a.m., the price had briefly dropped to $83.87.
That gives its shares a chance to hit or even fall below the previous day’s IPO price.
While highly unusual, this is not unheard of. A review of historical examples shows this has happened multiple times in the past.
Gaming vendor Zynga saw its share price drop by almost 10% on its first day. Meta, Uber, Robinhood and Peloton each closed below their IPO prices in their first sessions.
Over the years, multiple studies have questioned investments in IPOs. For example, Dimensional Fund Advisors, in August 2019, studied the performance of 6,362 U.S. IPOs from January 1991 to December 2018 for which data was available. The firm found that “IPOs have generally underperformed broader market benchmarks in recent decades and that their fundamental characteristics suggest lower expected returns.”
Many of them were smaller companies, but still, good performance isn’t something to depend on. Be aware of “potential adverse selection and post-offering activities, such as the expiration of insider lockup periods.”